Medela Freestyle Flex, Medela Swing | Portable Medela Breast Pumps Review 2025 – New Little Life
Today, we’re diving into a comprehensive look at some of Medela’s portable breast pumps. As a seasoned pump tester (with a closet full of breast pumps to prove it!), I’ll walk you through their features, usability, and suitability for various needs. Whether you’re a working mom or just need a reliable pumping option, this guide is for you. And hey, if you’re navigating your pumping journey and need personalized support, don’t forget to explore our coaching program.
(This post was originally a video. Check it out, here!)
Can Medela Keep Up with the Competition?
Medela has long been a trusted name in breastfeeding, known for producing durable and high-performing pumps. However, the competition in the portable pump space has increased, and while Medela remains a popular choice, some newer models may not top my personal favorites list. These pumps are often available through insurance or DME companies, which can make them an affordable option.
The Medela Freestyle Line
1. The Original Medela Freestyle
This workhorse pump has been around for years and is known for its reliability. It features a straightforward design and decent suction strength. However, it’s becoming harder to find, with availability mostly limited to resale platforms like eBay. While it’s functional, it lacks some modern features.
2. Medela Freestyle Flex
This updated model includes a redesigned flange system with removable shields, making it easier to find the perfect size. The oval shape fits more comfortably on the breast, and the flexible edges reduce cleaning hassle. Additionally, the valve and backflow protector are combined into one piece, simplifying setup and cleaning.
3. Medela Freestyle Flex Hands-Free
A newer addition to the Freestyle family, this pump includes hands-free cups. While not a true wearable pump (as the motor is separate), it offers more mobility. The cups are well-designed, easy to clean, and hold up to 5 ounces. However, inserts for smaller flange sizes may be hard to find.
The Medela Swing Line
1. Medela Swing
This compact and lightweight pump is often a single-sided option, making it less versatile for moms who need to pump both breasts simultaneously. Its simplicity and affordability make it an entry-level choice, but it may not be robust enough for exclusive pumping.
2. Medela Swing Maxi
The Swing Maxi is a double-pump version with a slightly more substantial build. It shares similarities with Medela’s Pump in Style MaxFlow but in a portable format. Simple controls and decent suction cycles make it a user-friendly option for light to moderate use.
Can You Make These Pumps Work?
These pumps may not be the top choice for every mom, but they can still work well for certain situations:
- Your insurance options are limited. These pumps are often available through DME or insurance companies, making them accessible when choices are restricted.
- You pump infrequently. If you’re home with your baby and pumping only occasionally, these pumps can handle lighter use.
- You value ease of use. The straightforward setup and simple cleaning process make these pumps convenient for beginners or those who prefer minimal fuss.
That said, these models may not be the best fit for moms who are exclusively pumping or need a pump with exceptional durability and efficiency. They’re solid, mid-range options but might not hold up under heavy, long-term use. If you’re relying heavily on a pump to manage your milk supply, you may want to explore other options.
Pros and Cons
Pros
- Freestyle Line: Portable, lightweight, and easy to use.
- Swing Line: Affordable, compact, and user-friendly.
- Both lines offer relatively fast cycle speeds, which align with studies suggesting that faster cycles promote milk ejection.
Cons
- Limited flange compatibility within the brand.
- Some models, particularly the Freestyle Flex, have touchscreens that are overly sensitive and prone to accidental activation.
- Noise levels can be a drawback, especially for moms seeking discretion.
Key Takeaways
While these Medela pumps may not top the list, they’re solid options when insurance constraints apply. The Freestyle Flex, in particular, stands out for its innovative flange design and ease of use. However, it’s worth exploring other pumps if you’re looking for something with a longer lifespan or quieter operation.
Need Help Picking the Right Pump?
Navigating the world of breast pumps can be overwhelming. Whether you’re returning to work or tackling exclusive pumping, our coaching program is here to support you. Gain confidence and knowledge to make the best choice for your lifestyle. Learn more here.
Let me know your experiences with Medela pumps in the comments below. Your feedback helps create a supportive community for all moms navigating their pumping journey
Meet Allison Tolman, LPN, IBCLC!
She is the owner and founder of New Little Life, a company dedicated to providing objective information and support for pumping mothers. With 15+ years of experience in various pregnancy and postpartum fields including as an LPN, birth doula, childbirth educator, and IBCLC, her current research focuses on testing and exploring breast pumps to find the most practical way to help pumping mothers reach their goals as well as teaching lactation professionals to better understand the complex art of pumping.
