How to Choose the Right Breast Pump for Your Needs: A Step-by-Step Guide

How to choose the right breast pump can feel overwhelming, especially with so many options on the market. Whether you’re a first-time mom or returning to pumping after a break, making the right choice requires evaluating your unique needs. Here’s a guide to simplify the process:

(This post was originally a video. Check it out, here!)


Assess Your Pumping Needs

Begin by considering how frequently you’ll need to pump. Are you:

  • Pumping occasionally to have a small backup supply?
  • Exclusively pumping to provide breastmilk for your baby?
  • Pumping as a working mom who needs a regular supply while away?

Each scenario demands a different pump. For instance, if you’re occasionally pumping, a basic, less expensive pump could meet your needs.

If you’re frequently or exclusively pumping investing in a high-quality, hospital-grade or dual motor pump for reliability and efficiency could be a good option. Choose a pump with a reputation for durability.


Consider Lifestyle Barriers

Evaluate your daily environment and lifestyle, which impacts the type of pump you’ll find most effective. Key factors to consider:

  • Work Environment: If you’re working in a quiet space, a quieter pump might be essential. For public spaces, you may prioritize a more discreet, wearable pump.
  • Mobility Needs: If you’ll be on the move, consider a portable pump with a rechargeable battery.
  • Home Setup: If you’re pumping primarily at home, a stationary pump with greater power and suction might work best.

Set Your Budget

Pump costs vary widely, from around $20 to over $500. It’s helpful to:

  • Check Insurance: In the U.S., most insurance companies cover the cost of a breast pump. Start by contacting your provider or consulting a DME (Durable Medical Equipment) company for guidance on covered options.
  • Decide on Extras: Determine if you can afford a second pump or spare parts. If insurance covers one pump, it might be worthwhile to purchase a portable option for flexibility.

Budgeting also includes considering ongoing costs, like replacement parts, which are sometimes covered by insurance if ordered through a DME.


Reflect on Previous Pumping Experience

If you’ve pumped before/ are an experienced pumper, think about what worked and what didn’t. You may want to try a new type or model with advanced features, especially if you’re familiar with your pumping needs and preferences.

On the other hand, if you’re a first-time pumper: Opt for a reliable, user-friendly pump with adjustable settings. Established models with positive reviews are usually a safer choice. Newer models with advanced technology can be great, but they often come with a learning curve. If you’re new to pumping, simplicity can reduce stress.


Determine the Must-Have Features

Consider which features are critical for your comfort and convenience:

  • Noise Level: If you need a quiet pump, look for models designed with noise-reduction features.
  • Portability and Battery Life: For moms on the move, a battery-operated or rechargeable pump is ideal.
  • Adjustability: Pumps with multiple suction levels and letdown settings can help you find the most comfortable fit.
  • Hands-Free Design: For moms who need flexibility, wearable pumps that fit inside a bra allow you to pump discreetly while doing other tasks.

These features vary by model and are often tailored to different needs, so prioritize what matters most to you.


Explore Different Pump Types

Now that you know your needs and preferences, it’s time to pick a pump type:

  • Standard Tabletop Pumps: Known for reliability, these models are ideal for exclusive pumpers. While some insurance options may be lower-end, you can often upgrade to a premium model.
  • Portable Pumps: Compact and battery-operated, portable pumps are great for working moms needing flexibility.
  • Wearable Pumps: These hands-free pumps fit inside a bra and work well for light, occasional pumping. While they’re convenient, wearables tend to produce less milk.
  • Hospital-Grade Pumps: These heavy-duty models are often rented and provide high suction power, ideal for those with specific lactation needs or for exclusive pumping.

Additional Resources on How to Choose the Right Breast Pump

In addition to this guide, several resources can support you in making your decision:

  • Facebook Group: Join a community dedicated to breast pump reviews and advice.
  • Webinar: Check out the “Best Breast Pumps for Working Moms” webinar for an in-depth review of specific brands.
  • Quiz: Take the New Little Life quiz to receive personalized pump recommendations.
  • Coaching Program: If you’re looking for one-on-one support, consider a coaching program to simplify the decision-making process.

Final Thoughts: Your Pump Choice Is Only Part of the Equation

Remember that while selecting a pump is important, effective pumping relies heavily on your practices. Consistency, proper fit, and a comfortable environment all contribute to a successful pumping experience.

How to choose the right breast pump doesn’t have to be an overwhelming question! Focus on what best fits your lifestyle, needs, and budget, you’ll be set up for pumping success. Happy pumping!

Meet Allison Tolman, LPN, IBCLC!

She is the owner and founder of New Little Life, a company dedicated to providing objective information and support for pumping mothers. With 15+ years of experience in various pregnancy and postpartum fields including as an LPN, birth doula, childbirth educator, and IBCLC, her current research focuses on testing and exploring breast pumps to find the most practical way to help pumping mothers reach their goals as well as teaching lactation professionals to better understand the complex art of pumping. 

She runs a long-term coaching program to support working mothers who are pumping

You might also like these posts: